PORTLAND, MAINE — The morning after deciding former President Donald Trump isn’t eligible to seem on Maine’s presidential major poll this yr, Maine Secretary of State Shenna Bellows started receiving a barrage of violent threats. By the point a swatting incident focusing on Bellows’ house occurred final Friday night time, her workplace telephones had been ringing off the hook all day.
“What was regarding on Friday was the extent of vitriol and simply abusive communications directed at my workers and moreover the threatening communications focusing on not solely me however my household and other people round me,” Bellows stated in an interview.
She was doxxed. Her house deal with and private cellular phone — referred to as continuously — had been posted on-line. Trump’s Fact Social directed his followers to her official web site.
“The quantity of calls appears to have been bigger than the quantity of emails,” Bellows stated. “Civil servants working in state authorities should not be on the receiving finish of communications starting from profanity to worse.”
Relying who you speak to in Maine, Bellows is both a brave hero or a political hack for changing into the primary state election official to ever disqualify a candidate for federal workplace beneath Part 3 of the 14th Modification to the Structure.
“I made this choice primarily based on the details, the proof, the regulation, and the Structure, as introduced within the listening to”
And there’s very restricted time — lower than three weeks — to reverse her choice, for those who want that consequence.
The Trump marketing campaign has till this Friday, January 5, to attraction the Bellows choice to Maine Superior Courtroom and plans to take action.
“After all, I’m involved for my security,” stated Bellows, who has police safety. “That is unacceptable. It’s unacceptable that any elected official ought to be focused simply because persons are indignant or disagree with their views.”
Over the New Yr’s vacation weekend, Bellows revealed in a Fb publish one of many “continuous” threats had focused her and her husband, Brandon, within the swatting incident — a phony emergency name to impress an pressing police response — at their house in Manchester, Maine, 4 miles outdoors the capital of Augusta. They weren’t house.
After receiving an emergency name shortly after 8:00 p.m. Friday from an unknown man claiming to have damaged into the house, Maine State Police searched it and the grounds however discovered nobody or something suspicious.
Bellows wrote on Fb the swatting and threats had been “designed to scare not solely me but additionally others into silence, to ship a message.”
“Please encourage these whom you affect to de-escalate the rhetoric,” Bellows continued on Fb. “Dehumanizing an individual is step one in paving the best way for assaults and violence in opposition to them.”
The Maine Democratic Occasion referred to as the threats “deeply alarming,” noting that Bellows is “required to find out the eligibility and validity of petitions for public workplace,” together with President, and did so for a number of candidates for the upcoming major.
Bellows added in our interview, “For anybody who’s upset with the regulation that requires the Secretary of State to carry a listening to and difficulty a ruling on the eligibility of a presidential candidate, there’s a mechanism for altering the regulation. However to assault me for doing my job, and to assault, extra importantly, my workers, the folks round me, and my household, is unsuitable, and it must cease. It’s extremely harmful. It’s symptomatic of what’s taking place proper now in our nation. We have to get up and urge everybody, our family and friends members, to convey civility and respect to those conversations.”
A CONTROVERSIAL DECISION
Bellows, a Democrat who denied Trump entry to the state’s March 5 poll as he seeks to safe the Republican presidential nomination in his third run for the White Home, insists partisanship had nothing to do along with her choice.
“My oath to the Structure is my utmost and sole obligation on this matter. My political affiliation and political opinions of January 6, 2021, didn’t play a job on this choice,” Bellows stated in our interview.
Her 34-page choice on December 28 discovered Trump’s declaration on his candidate consent type was false, as a result of he’s not certified to carry the workplace of the President beneath Part 3 of the 14th Modification, which forbids anybody who has “engaged in rebellion or rebel” in opposition to the Structure after taking an oath to uphold it, until forgiven in by two-thirds majority votes within the U.S. Home and Senate.
“I don’t attain this conclusion evenly. Democracy is sacred,” Bellows wrote in her choice.
Primaries and caucuses awarding delegates to the summer time nomination conventions start this month in Iowa and New Hampshire.
Maine’s presidential major is scheduled for March 5, together with 15 different states, which is why it’s referred to as Tremendous Tuesday. The checklist consists of Colorado, the place the State Supreme Courtroom selected December 19 Trump is ineligible for its major poll.
Colorado Secretary of State Jena Griswold, who was not a celebration to the choice, expressed solidarity with Bellows over the vacation weekend and revealed that she too has acquired threats.
“Inside three weeks of the lawsuit being filed, I acquired 64 dying threats. I finished counting after that,” Griswold said on X. “I can’t be intimidated. Democracy and peace will overcome tyranny and violence.”
Bellows, 48, is the first girl to function Maine’s Secretary of State.
The Democratic-controlled State Legislature selected her, not the voters, in December 2020, because it additionally does for the state’s lawyer normal and treasurer beneath the Maine structure.
Bellows concluded a pair of Maine statutes governing poll petition assessment grant her the authority to disqualify Trump.
Candidates should gather 2,000 signatures from voters registered of their occasion voters by December 1, and fill out a candidate consent type affirming, “I meet the {qualifications} to carry this workplace as listed above” — at the very least 35 years-old, a pure born U.S. citizen, and a resident of the USA for at the very least 14 years — as outlined by the Article 2, Part 1 of the U.S. Structure.
JANUARY 6 IN MAINE
The January 6 Capitol riot occurred on Bellows’ third day on the job.
On the Maine State Home on January 6, there have been issues of a possible copycat siege, as 85 to 100 Trump supporters gathered outdoors. However they dispersed with out incident.
“In America, the voters decide our leaders. Not Congress, not an armed mob can overturn an election,” Bellows instructed me in an interview in her workplace on the State Home grounds that day.
She had been one of many 4 Maine electors who ratified the outcomes the month earlier than, casting her vote for Joe Biden.
“These elections had been among the most safe we have now seen on this nation. The outcomes had been crystal clear. The Electoral School upheld the desire of the folks,” Bellows stated on January 6.
For a story broadcast on the primary anniversary of the Capitol assault, I interviewed Bellows about two payments she advocated for with a purpose to shield election employees and voting machines. Each had been handed by the legislature and signed by Governor Janet Mills. One made it a felony in Maine to threaten election employees or hinder their duties. The opposite banned out-of-state teams from conducting post-election audits, as occurred in Arizona after the 2020 presidential race.
In a tweet linking to that story, Bellows wrote, “One yr after the violent rebellion, it’s vital to do all we will to safeguard our elections.” Trump’s legal professionals flagged that tweet and different previous social media posts by Bellows, on the eve of her poll eligibility choice, to argue she was biased and will recuse herself. Bellows rejected the movement as premature. It was previous the deadline for evidentiary briefs and submissions.
Trump speeches and tweets had been proven on the day-long December 19 public listening to that Bellows presided over on the State Home.
“I made this choice primarily based on the details, the proof, the regulation, and the Structure, as introduced within the listening to,” she instructed me.
Her choice disqualifying Trump bluntly assigned blame for the riot to the previous president because the election-denier-in-chief and rejected the notion that the riot that stopped the Electoral School certification was a spontaneous occasion.
“The central query,” Bellows wrote in her choice, “is whether or not Mr. Trump’s statements and different conduct main as much as and together with January 6…represent incitement of rebellion.”
Trump had sowed seeds of mistrust within the election outcomes months earlier than Election Day by demonizing the demand for mail-in ballots that soared that yr as a result of coronavirus pandemic. Two-thirds of Maine voters forged absentee ballots within the 2020 normal election.
“The report establishes that Mr. Trump, over the course of a number of months and culminating on January 6, 2021, used a false narrative of election fraud to inflame his supporters and direct them to the Capitol to stop certification of the 2020 election and the peaceable switch of energy,” Bellows wrote within the choice. “Mr. Trump was conscious of the probability for violence and at the very least initially supported its use given he each inspired it with incendiary rhetoric and took no well timed motion to cease it.”
Threats to ballot employees and election officers in Maine and across the nation arose as Trump created a disaster of confidence in election integrity even earlier than he refused to just accept shedding 5 swing states to Joe Biden that he had received in 2020 — Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Georgia, and Arizona.
In the long run, Biden received 306 electoral votes to Trump’s 232. Biden received 51.3% of the nationwide standard vote and seven million extra votes than Trump’s 46.9%. The elections of 2000, 2004, and 2016 had been nearer.
Round 10 Mainers have been prosecuted for collaborating within the Capitol riot, together with Kyle Fitzsimons, who’s now serving a seven-year sentence in federal jail primarily for assaulting regulation enforcement officers defending the West Terrace entrance to the constructing.
In her choice, Bellows blamed Trump’s “cease the steal” and “struggle like hell” rhetoric for the Capitol riot and located his restricted feedback because the violence unfolded inadequate at quelling the mob.
She concluded, “Mr. Trump’s occasional requests that rioters be peaceable and help regulation enforcement don’t immunize his actions. A short name to obey the regulation doesn’t erase conduct over the course of months, culminating in his speech on the Ellipse. The burden of the proof makes clear that Mr. Trump was conscious of the tinder laid by his multi-month effort to delegitimize a democratic election, after which selected to mild a match.”
MAINE REACTIONS
The Maine challengers to Trump’s candidacy stated Bellows’ choice confirmed “nice braveness” and “stood on the facet of democracy and our structure.”
“President Trump violated his presidential oath when he tried to dam the peaceable switch of energy by inciting an rebellion on January 6, 2021. For that act, as affirmed by each the Colorado Supreme Courtroom and Secretary Bellows, our structure bars him from endlessly once more holding workplace in the USA,” former state legislators Ethan Strimiling, Tom Saviello, and Kim Rosen stated in a written assertion. “We look ahead to serving to her defend her considered and proper choice in courtroom. No elected official is above the regulation or our structure.
Trump marketing campaign spokesman Steven Chueng referred to as Bellows, a former state senator, U.S. Senate candidate, and government director of the Maine Civil Liberties Union, “a virulent leftist and a hyper-partisan Biden-supporting Democrat” and described her choice as an “tried theft of an election and the disenfranchisement of the American voter.”
Had Trump been convicted in his second impeachment trial within the U.S. Senate — in February 2021, for inciting the Capitol riot — he might need been barred from holding workplace once more.
Maine Senator Susan Collins was considered one of seven Republicans, together with all 50 Democrats and Independents, to vote for a responsible verdict, however 10 extra Republicans had been wanted for the required two-thirds majority to convict. Collins, who opposes Trump’s candidacy in 2024, co-authored the Electoral Rely Reform Act to make one other January 6 situation unimaginable by clarifying the restricted, ministerial position of the vice chairman within the election ratification course of. However Collins was fast to reject Bellows’ choice, posting on X, “Maine voters ought to determine who wins the election – not a Secretary of State chosen by the legislature. The Secretary of State’s choice would deny 1000’s of Mainers the chance to vote for the candidate of their selection, and it ought to be overturned.”
Democratic Consultant Jared Golden, who represents the conservative-leaning 2nd Congressional District, which Trump carried in 2016 and 2020, securing one electoral vote every time, additionally disagreed with Bellows. Golden posted on X, “I voted to question Donald Trump for his position within the January 6 rebellion. I don’t imagine he ought to be re-elected President of the USA. Nonetheless, we’re a nation of legal guidelines, and subsequently, till he’s truly discovered responsible of the crime of rebellion, he ought to be allowed on the poll.”
Desire a each day wrap-up of all of the information and commentary Salon has to supply? Subscribe to our morning publication, Crash Course.
Maine Impartial Senator Angus King, who’s working for a 3rd time period in 2024, said he respected Bellows’ “careful process” however “absent a ultimate judicial willpower of a violation of the 14th Modification’s disqualification clause, I imagine the choice as as to if or not Mr. Trump ought to once more be thought of for the presidency ought to relaxation with the folks as expressed in free and honest elections.”
The one member of the congressional delegation to again Bellows is Democratic Consultant Chellie Pingree, who represents the liberal 1st Congressional District, encompassing Portland and Southern Maine.
“Donald Trump incited a violent mob to dam Congress from certifying the Electoral School + overturn the 2020 presidential election,” Pingree posted on X. “The textual content of the Fourteenth Modification is obvious. No one that engaged in an rebellion in opposition to the federal government can ever once more serve in elected workplace.”
The U.S. Supreme Courtroom seems destined to contemplate the Maine and Colorado choices and others barring Trump from the poll.
Thus far, courts and election officers in California, Michigan, Minneota, Oregon, and different states have declined to dam Trump from their 2024 ballots. GOP Senator Thom Tillis, of North Carolina, who called the Bellows decision “an egregious abuse of energy,”plans to introduce a invoice to impound federal election administration funds for states “misusing the 14th Modification for political functions.”
NEXT STEPS
Bellows suspended her choice till the Maine Superior Courtroom, the Maine Supreme Courtroom, and different venues, as crucial, have a chance to weigh in on appeals.
However the timetable stays compressed. Maine’s presidential major ballots, beneath state regulation, have to be printed and despatched to army and abroad voters 45 days earlier than the election, or by January 20.
Bellows, whose time period expires in 2025, ran for statewide elective workplace earlier than, shedding the 2014 U.S. Senate race in opposition to Collins. Governor Mills is serving her second and ultimate time period, and the following Maine gubernatorial election is in 2026.
Once I requested Bellows if she thought of the impression of her choice on any future political aspirations, she replied, “No.”
No consideration of the private or political penalties? “None.”
She’s instructed me she’s not anxious about being impeached or shedding the belief of voters as being a dependable supply of election info.
Bellows, who isn’t a lawyer, is receiving authorized counsel from the workplace of Maine’s Lawyer Normal.
“That is my choice,” Bellows stated in our interview. “My choice was primarily based completely on the details introduced to me on the listening to and my obligations beneath the regulation and the Structure.”
Learn extra
about this matter