Within the two years after the revolt of January 6, 2021, it appeared that the Proud Boys — the far-right militia that had been the vanguard for storming the Capitol — had been simply getting stronger. Whereas they’d failed to assist Donald Trump steal the 2020 election, the group gained prominence and gave the impression to be rising in dimension. As Kathryn Joyce reported for Salon, the Proud Boys refocused on harassing LGBTQ folks at public occasions, glomming onto the Mothers for Liberty-led assault on faculty boards, and presenting themselves as shock troops for Christian nationalism. By placing themselves on the heart of the tradition warfare, the group was capable of hold getting consideration and, seemingly, new members.
In 2023, nonetheless, the Proud Boys seemed to be “circling the drain,” experiences Tess Owen of Vice, who has coated the Proud Boys for years. Whereas warning that the group remains to be a violent menace, particularly to LGBTQ folks, there may be little doubt that they’ve seen a dramatic decline in exercise. There have been “simply 36 uniformed appearances by a number of Proud Boys throughout 17 states final yr, in comparison with the 63 appearances throughout 21 states that we logged in 2022,” Owens writes. The occasions they did have had comparatively low turnout, as nicely.
There’s a couple of issues happening. As Owens notes, it is common for extremist teams to collapse pretty shortly. They’re composed of nasty individuals who search battle, so it is inevitable that they struggle and splinter over time. There’s proof some Proud Boys are decamping to neo-Nazi teams. I might argue that the Proud Boys are impacted by the identical forces which might be inflicting Mothers for Liberty to falter. Republicans guess huge into 2022 on far-right teams, however as an alternative, the GOP underperformed within the 2022 and 2023 elections. The backfire impact is lowering enthusiasm for this new breed of tradition warriors.
However there’s one huge issue that can not be missed that made 2023 very completely different from 2022: Proud Boys lastly began going to jail for his or her position in January 6.
Need extra Amanda Marcotte on politics? Subscribe to her publication Standing Room Solely.
In Might 2023, Proud Boys chief Enrique Tarrio and 4 of his high lieutenants had been discovered responsible of crimes dedicated throughout the Capitol revolt. The verdicts had been very severe. 4 of them had been discovered responsible of seditious conspiracy, whereas a fifth was convicted for assaulting a police officer. The shortest sentence was 10 years. Tarrio acquired 22 years, and can seemingly serve most, if not all of it.
That was essentially the most outstanding case, however there’s been a gentle drip-drip of tales about Proud Boys receiving authorized penalties. A sampling in latest months of Proud Boys going through justice within the courtroom system: Charles Donohoe pled responsible and was sentenced to 40 months in December for his position within the revolt. The identical month, Anthony Sargent acquired 5 years after a responsible plea. Christopher Worrell was sentenced to 10 years in January, regardless of faking a drug overdose to flee his listening to.
Information from The Armed Battle Location & Occasion Information (ACLED) Undertaking exhibits that whereas there was a gradual decline in Proud Boys exercise within the first half of 2023, there was a preciptious drop-off within the mid-summer, dwindling to almost nothing by the tip of the yr. This concides with the convictions and sentencing of Tarrio and different high Proud Boys. It is extremely unlikely that is a coincidence. As a substitute, it suggests strongly that these high-profile punishments have efficiently scared different Proud Boys into retreat.
To many individuals, this would appear an apparent end result. Our jail system is meant to work as deterrence, and definitely the prosecutors argued that is why they sought prolonged sentences that may garner numerous consideration. However there’s additionally no finish of pundits nowadays who’re able to warn that efforts to carry authoritarians to account will solely backfire. They declare that the MAGA motion will solely develop stronger if the authorized system enforces the regulation as it’s written.
Granted, most of these arguments are made not a lot about Proud Boys, however about Donald Trump. Each time a lawyer or a decide tries to impose legally mandated penalties on Trump for his multitude of crimes, a refrain rises as much as yowl that he’ll solely get stronger for it. And it’s true that, inside the Republican social gathering, voters rallied to help Trump after he was indicted on 91 felony expenses throughout 4 jurisdictions. This has triggered some observers, even ostensible liberals, to deal with any effort to carry Trump accountable as a mistake that can inevitably backfire. The newest iteration is the bed-wetters arguing that eradicating Trump from the poll, which is required by the 14th modification, will result in his victory in November.
Trump himself, naturally, hypes this concept that the MAGA motion will solely be emboldened by efforts to convey him to justice. After an appeals courtroom listening to Tuesday, wherein it appeared the judges are poised to shoot down his claims that he’s “immune” to felony prosecution, Trump returned to that nicely. “It’ll be bedlam within the nation,” if the courts allow him to be tried for his tried coup, he warned. Actually, nonetheless, it was a menace: That the MAGA motion can be outraged and stand up, with implied violence, to forestall any penalties for earlier violence.
This rhetoric scares many. And little doubt that MAGA is a grievance-fueled motion that can seize on this as an outrage to rally round. However most People already dislike Trump and the MAGA motion. The principle results of authorized penalties is to solely reinforce that dangerous opinion. That is particularly seemingly with swing voters, who might be reminded of what a foul man Trump is, and will not be stoked to face by a felony convicted by a jury of his friends.
Need extra Amanda Marcotte on politics? Subscribe to her publication Standing Room Solely.
However authorized penalties for Trump will not be a lift of confidence within the MAGA motion some consider. MAGA is a fascist motion that worships what they understand as power. To them, “power” is evading penalties for dangerous actions. When their leaders are held to account, nonetheless, that’s demoralizing and, crucially, demobilizing for the appropriate.
The information on the Proud Boys, whereas incomplete, does a very good job of displaying how this works. Even whereas their leaders had been below indictment, the Proud Boys may inform themselves a narrative about how they had been a mighty pressure, capable of commit crimes in broad daylight with out paying the penalty for it. As quickly as their leaders went to jail, nonetheless, their members beat a quick retreat. They might be yelling at one another on Telegram about all of the liberals they need to “set off,” however they are not as eager anymore on going out in public to begin fights. Odds are excessive one thing related will occur if Trump’s aura of invincibility is penetrated by severe penalties, like a felony conviction. His supporters who at present worship him like a god might be reminded he is only a man — and a whiny one who smells like a butt, at that.
Much more importantly, we should always not flinch from holding Trump acountable as a result of in any other case, it is an invite to fascists to go even additional. As Brian Beutler wrote in a latest publication, “it’s needed within the face of corrosive threats to jettison info and switch all of politics and regulation right into a contest of will to abuse energy.” Sure, maybe we lose if we put up a struggle towards fascism. However we have already misplaced if we roll over and let the criminals run free.